Last reviewed: April 2025
Handball
SoccerWhy do some handballs get called and others don't?
Rule
Handball is called when a player (other than the goalkeeper in their own area) deliberately touches the ball with their hand or arm, or when the ball touches their arm or hand in a position that has made their body unnaturally larger. The arm boundary runs from the bottom of the armpit.
Common Misconception
The biggest misconception is that any contact between ball and arm is a handball. The law requires either deliberate touch or an arm positioned in a way that makes the body unnaturally larger. An arm tucked against the torso, hanging naturally by the side, or moving in a direction the player has committed to — these are generally not handball.
What Matters in the Moment
Referees look at arm position (is it natural or raised?), the distance of the shot or cross (was there time to react?), and whether any goal or clear goalscoring opportunity was created directly from the touch. A ball ricocheting from a player's own foot to their arm in a split second is treated differently than a player extending an arm to block a cross.
Ruleset Note
The handball law was rewritten in 2019 and again clarified in 2022. The current standard distinguishes 'deliberate' handball from 'accidental' handball that results in a goal or goal chance. A goal is disallowed if the scorer's own hand/arm touched the ball immediately before they scored — even accidentally. Accidental handball by a different teammate earlier in the build-up does not disallow the goal under the current law.
Realistic Example
The Call
A defender slides to block a shot. The ball strikes their outstretched arm at shoulder height. Likely a penalty — the arm is in a position that makes the body larger. But the referee still considers whether the arm position was a natural consequence of the slide and whether there was time to react; the 2022 clarifications moved away from treating any arm above the shoulder as automatic.
The Murky Case
A cross deflects off one attacker's knee onto another attacker's arm, and that same attacker scores. Goal disallowed — the rule disallows goals scored immediately after the ball touched the scorer's own arm, even accidentally. Different scenario: if the deflection went off attacker A's arm to attacker B who scored cleanly, the goal stands under the current law — A's accidental handball doesn't carry through to B.
Honest Take
Handball has become one of the most debated calls in the game because the law has tried to balance objectivity (arm position) with subjectivity (intent). The result satisfies no one fully. A strict reading catches defenders who aren't trying to cheat; a lenient reading lets obvious blocks go. Referees are caught applying a law that the lawmakers themselves keep revising.
Last reviewed: April 2025
Get the ref's perspective on your game
Describe what happened. We'll explain what the referee was looking at and whether the call holds up.
Analyze a call →Free — no account required for your first calls