Last reviewed: April 2025
Free Kicks
SoccerDirect vs. indirect and why the wall distance matters
Rule
A direct free kick is awarded for physical contact offenses under Law 12 — tripping, pushing, striking, charging, jumping at, holding, tackling, or impeding an opponent with contact — and for handball. A goal can be scored directly. An indirect free kick is awarded for offside, dangerous play, impeding the progress of an opponent without contact, goalkeeper infractions, or other technical violations. A goal can only be scored if the ball touches another player before entering the net — including a deflection off the goalkeeper. If an indirect free kick is shot directly into the net without any other touch, no goal is awarded; the restart is a goal kick. The defending wall must be at least 10 yards (9.15 m) from the ball. When three or more defenders form a wall, all attacking players must stay at least 1 meter away from it until the ball is in play.
Common Misconception
Many players and fans don't know the difference between direct and indirect in the moment. The referee signals indirect by holding one arm raised vertically until the ball is touched a second time — if that arm stays up, you need a second touch before a goal counts. The other misconception is around who can encroach. Most people know the wall must respect 10 yards. Fewer know that attacking players can also be penalized for crowding the wall — and the consequences are different depending on which side encroaches.
What Matters in the Moment
Referees signal the kick type clearly. For indirect, the raised arm stays up until the second touch. On wall distance: defenders must retreat immediately; a yellow card is the consequence for failing to respect the 10 yards. If a defender encroaches and the kick is taken quickly, the referee allows play to continue — a goal in that sequence stands. On attacking encroachment: if an attacking player is within 1 meter of a wall of three or more defenders when the kick is taken, the defending team is awarded an indirect free kick. No card, no retake of the original kick — possession goes back to the defending team. The asymmetry most people don't know: defending wall encroachment results in a retake with a yellow; attacking encroachment into the wall hands possession back to the defending team entirely.
Ruleset Note
The 10-yard (9.15 m) distance applies to all free kicks anywhere on the field — not just the final third. Some competitions use vanishing spray to mark the ball position and the 10-yard line, but it is not required by the Laws of the Game. If a player takes a free kick quickly and an opponent who is less than 9.15 m from the ball intercepts it, the referee allows play to continue — a goal scored directly in this scenario is allowed.
Realistic Example
The Call
Referee awards an indirect free kick for dangerous play. The taker shoots directly into the net without the ball touching anyone. Referee disallows it — goal kick awarded. The raised arm was the signal: this needed a second touch.
The Murky Case
The defending wall encroaches to 8 yards and the attacking team takes the kick immediately. The ball goes in. Goal stands — the attacking team accepted the encroachment by taking the kick. Now flip it: an attacking player is within 1 meter of the wall when the kick is taken. No card, no retake — the defending team is awarded an indirect free kick from where they were standing. The attacking team just handed possession back.
Honest Take
Most free kick disputes start with the foul call itself — one sideline thinks it was obvious, the other thinks nothing happened. The mechanics that follow (wall distance, encroachment, direct vs. indirect) are secondary noise. The direct/indirect distinction matters enormously on the rare occasion it applies, and players caught off-guard by an indirect in a dangerous position almost always concede — but that's not what anyone is arguing about on the way home.
Last reviewed: April 2025
Get the ref's perspective on your game
Describe what happened. We'll explain what the referee was looking at and whether the call holds up.
Analyze a call →Free — no account required for your first calls